دورية أكاديمية

Validation of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation mortality prediction and severity of illness scores in an international COVID-19 cohort

التفاصيل البيبلوغرافية
العنوان: Validation of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation mortality prediction and severity of illness scores in an international COVID-19 cohort
المؤلفون: Shah N., Xue B., Xu Z., Yang H., Marwali E., Dalton H., Payne P. P. R., Lu C., Said A. S., Abdukahil S. A., Abdulkadir N. N., Absil L., Acker A., Adriao D., Hssain A. A., Akwani C., Qasim E. A., Alalqam R., Al-Dabbous T., Alex B., Al-Fares A., Alfoudri H., Aliudin J., Alves J., Alves R., Alves J. M., Cabrita J. A., Amaral M., Amira N., Andini R., Anthonidass S., Antonelli M., Arabi Y., Arcadipane A., Arenz L., Arnold-Day C., Arora L., Arora R., Ashraf M., Asyraf A., Atique A., Bach B., Baillie J. K., Bak E., Bakar N. A., Balakrishnan M., Barbalho R., Barclay W. S., Barnett S. U., Barnikel M., Barrasa H., Barrigoto C., Baruch J., Hassin Basri M. F., Battaglini D., Bautista Rincon D. F., Bee K. H., Begum H., Beljantsev A., Benjiman L. E., Bento L., Bernal Sobrino J. L., Bertolino L., Bhatt A., Bianco C., Bidin F. N., Humaid F. B., Bin Kamarudin M. N., Blanco-Schweizer P., Bloos F., Boccia F., Bogaert D., Borges D., Bouhmani D., Bouziotis J., Boylan M., Bozza F. A., Brazzi L., Brewster D., Brickell K., Broadley T., Brozzi N., Buchtele N., Burrell A., Cabral S., Cabrita J., Garces R. C., Calligy K., Campbell P., Cardoso S., Cardoso F., Carelli S., Carrier F. M., Carson G., Cascao M., Casimiro J., Castanheira N., Castro I., Catarino A., Cavalin R., Cavalli G. G., Cavayas A., Chand M., Chen A., Chen Y. -S., Cheng M. P., Chica J., Chidambaram S. K., Tho L. C., Cho S. -M., Chow T. S., Chua H. J., Chua J., Cidade J. P., Citarella B. W., Ciullo A., Clarke J., Clohisey S., Codan C., Coles J., Colombo S. M., Connor M., Cooke G. S., Corley A., Cornelis S., Corpuz A. J., Crump J., Cruz C., Cruz Bermudez J. L., Rojo J. C., Csete M., Cullen A., Cummings M., Curley G., Custodio P., Filipe A. S., Dabaliz A. -A., Dagens A., Dahly D., Dalton J., Damas J., Dankwa E. A., Dantas J., de Loughry G., de Rosa R., de Silva T., Deacon J., Dean D., Debenedictis B., Dell'Amore A., Denis E., Depuydt P., Desai M., Dhangar P., Diaz R., Dieperink W., Docherty A. B., Doherty H., Donnelly C. A., Donohue C., Downer T., Drake T., Duculan T., Dunning J., Duplaix M., Durante-Mangoni E., Durham L., Ean S. C., Echeverria-Villalobos M., Elotmani L., Elshazly T., Eng C. C., Escher M., Santo C. E., Estevao J., Everding A. G., Fairfield C. J., Faria P., Fateena H., Fayed M., Fernandes J., Fernandes M. A., Fernandes S., Ferrao J., Ferraz M., Ferreira B., Figueiredo-Mello C., Fiorda J., Fletcher T., Florio L. L., Fonseca T., Forsyth S., Foti G., Fowler R. A., Fraser J. F., Fraser C., Ribeiro A. F., French C., Fukuda M., G A., Gagliardi M., Gaiao S., Gamble C., Gani Y., Garcia R., Barrio N. G., Gavin A., Germano N., Giani M., Gilroy E., Girvan M., Gnall E., Goffard J. -C., Goh J. Y., Golob J., Gonzalez A., Graf J., Grasselli G., Green C. A., Greenhalf W., Grieco D. L., Griffee M., Griffiths F., Lordemann A. G., Gruner H., Gu Y., Guerreiro D., Castro M. G., Hakak S., Hall M., Halpin S., Hamer A., Hammond T., Hammond N., Han L. Y., Hao K. W., Hardwick H., Ekow Harrison S. B., Harrison E. M., Harrison J., Heerman J., Hendry R., Hennessy M., Higgins D., Higgins R., Hinton S., Ho Y. B., Ho A., Hoh W. H., Holt R., Horby P., Hsu J. M. -Y., Hurd A., Ijaz S., Inacio H., Ing Y. S., Isgett S., Isidoro T., Ismail N., Ivulich D., Jackson C., Jelani A. M., Joe O. Y., Joshi S., Jung A., Kaisbain N., Kaleesvran T., Ayadi Kamaluddin M. A., Che Kamaruddin Z. A., Kamarudin N., Kang K. Y., Karpayah P., Kartsonaki C., Kay C., Keating S., Kelly A., Kelly S., Kennon K., Khalid I., Khan I., Kho M. E., Khoo R., Khoo D., Khoo S., Kiat K. H., Kida Y., Kim J. B., Kitamura N., Klenerman P., Knight S. R., Kobbe R., Krishnan V., Kumar D., Kumar G., Kurtzman E., Lalueza A., Lanza M., Law A., Lee T. C., Lee H. G., Lee B. H., Lee Y. L., Lee J., Leeming G., Lene H. S., Leone M., Bassi G. L., Lim K. C., Lim W. S., Lina L., Liu K., Loforte A., Loon L. C., Lopes D., Low L. L., Loy J. S., Bermejo C. L., Lunn M., Lyons R., Maasikas O., Machado S., de la Calle G. M., Maier L. S., Malfertheiner M., Malik N., Sant'ana Malaque C. M., Marino D., Marques A., Marsh B., Marsh L., Marshall J., Martin E., Martinez F. E., Martin-Loeches I., Martins J., Martins A., Rego C. M., Martucci G., Marzukie M., Maynar J., McArthur C., McCanny P., McCloskey C., McDermott S., McDonald S. E., McElroy A., McElwee S., McEvoy N., McKay C., McKeown J., McLean K. A., Mele F., Menkiti O., Mentzer A. J., Mergler B., Merson L., Mesquita A., Meynert A. M., Mihnovit V., Miller J., Misnan N. A., Mohamed T. J., Eliza Mohamed N. N., Moin A., Mone M., Monteiro A., Montes C., Montrucchio G., Moore S. C., Moore S., Motos A., Muh N. Y., Muhamad D., Murphy A., Murthy S., Muyandy G., Nagpal D., Nagrebetsky A., Neto R., Neumann E., Ng W. Y., Choileain O. N., Nichol A. D., Nitayavardhana P., Nonas S., Mohd Noordin N. A., Izzati Norharizam N. F., Norman L., Noursadeghi M., Occhipinti G., O'Donnell M., Ogura T., Oliveira J., Olliaro P. L., Ong J. Y., Oosthuyzen W., Openshaw P., Ortoleva J., Osatnik J., Othman S. Z., Palmarini M., Panarello G., Panda P. K., Pang L. H., Panigada M., Parke R., Patauner F., Pathmanathan M. D., Patterson L., Paulos J., Paxton W. A., Peake S. L., Peariasamy K., Jimenez M. P., Pelosi P., Pereira R., Periel L., Pesenti A., Pimentel C., Pires C., Pius R., Png H. S., Poli S., Pollakis G., Post A. -M., Postma D. F., Povoa P., Povoas D., Preiser J. -C., Pritchard M. G., Proenca L., Semedi B. P., Quesada L., Quinones-Cardona V., Gonzalez V. Q., Quraishi M., Rafael A., Rahman R. A., Rahman A. K. H. A., Rajahram G. S., Ramalho J., Ramli A. A., Ramos G. V., Rangappa R., Ratsep I., Rau C., Ravi T., Reis R., Rello J., Ren H., Richardson D., Ahmad Ridzuan S. N. A., Rios A. L., Robba C., Roberto A., Roberts S., Robertson D. L., Rodeia S., Roessler B., Roger C., Rojek A., Roncon-Albuquerque R., Rose M., Rosenberger D., Rossetti M., Russell C. D., Ryckaert S., Saba I., Sadat M., Sakiyalak P., Salazar L., Sales G., Sanchez E., Sancho-Shimizu V., Sandhu G., Santos M., Satyapriya S., Saviciute E., Saw Y. T., Schaffer J., Schermer T., Schwameis M., Scott J. T., Scott-Brown J., Selvarajoo M., Semple M. G., Senian R. B., Sequeira F., Sequeira T., Neto A. S., Balazote P. S., Shahidan S. A., Shamsah M., Sharma P., Shaw C. A., Shaw V., Shetty R. M., Shi H., Shimizu H., Shimizu K., Shrapnel S., Shum H. P., Siang N. Y., Sigfrid L., Sillaots P., Silva C., Heng B. S. L., Singh P., Singh M., Sivam K., Smith S., Smood B., Smyth C., Snacken M., Soh T. V., Solomon J., Solomon T., Somers E., Song M. J., Sousa M., Uva M. S., Sperry A., Sriskandan S., Staudinger T., Stecher S. -S., Stienstra Y., Stolz E., Stuart A., Stuart D., Suen J. Y., Summers C., Suppiah D., Syahrin S., Sztajnbok J., Szuldrzynski K., Tabrizi S., Taccone F. S., Taib S. M., Taleb S., Talsma J., Tan K. K., Tan Y. C., Tedder R. S., Tee T. Y., Teixeira J., Tejada S., Teoh S. K., Terpstra P., Tessier-Grenier H., Thabit A. A. M., Tham Z. D., Thangavelu S., Thirumanickam J., Thompson S., Thomson D., Thomson E. C., Thorpe M., Thurai S. R. T., Thwaites R. S., Toh J. Z. Y., Tonnii S. L., Torre M., Torres A., Towers M., Trapani T., Turtle L. C. W., Udy A., Ullrich R., Uribe A., Usman A., Uyeki T. M., Val-Flores L., Van de Velde S., Van Der Vekens N., Van der Voort P., Vanoverschelde H., Vasudayan S. R., Veeran S., Ventura S., Vidal J. E., Vieira C., Villanueva J. A., Vitiello C., Wahab N. H., Wahab S. A., Wahid N. A., Wang C. -H., Webb S., Wei J., Wen T. P., Wham M., White N., Wille K., Williams B., Williams V., Williams P. J., Wong C., Wong X. C., Wong Y. S., Wong T. F., Xian G. E., Xian L. S., Xuan K. P., Mohd Yakop S. R. B., Yamazaki M., Yarad E., Hing N. Y. L., Yeoh C. H., Yerkovich S., Yokoyama T., Zaaqoq A., Zahid M., Binti Zaidan N. Z., Zambon M., Zanella A., Zaynah N.
المساهمون: Shah, N, Xue, B, Xu, Z, Yang, H, Marwali, E, Dalton, H, Payne, P, Lu, C, Said, A, Abdukahil, S, Abdulkadir, N, Absil, L, Acker, A, Adriao, D, Hssain, A, Akwani, C, Qasim, E, Alalqam, R, Al-Dabbous, T, Alex, B, Al-Fares, A, Alfoudri, H, Aliudin, J, Alves, J, Alves, R, Cabrita, J, Amaral, M, Amira, N, Andini, R, Anthonidass, S, Antonelli, M, Arabi, Y, Arcadipane, A, Arenz, L, Arnold-Day, C, Arora, L, Arora, R, Ashraf, M, Asyraf, A, Atique, A, Bach, B, Baillie, J, Bak, E, Bakar, N, Balakrishnan, M, Barbalho, R, Barclay, W, Barnett, S, Barnikel, M, Barrasa, H, Barrigoto, C, Baruch, J, Hassin Basri, M, Battaglini, D, Bautista Rincon, D, Bee, K, Begum, H, Beljantsev, A, Benjiman, L, Bento, L, Bernal Sobrino, J, Bertolino, L, Bhatt, A, Bianco, C, Bidin, F, Humaid, F, Bin Kamarudin, M, Blanco-Schweizer, P, Bloos, F, Boccia, F, Bogaert, D, Borges, D, Bouhmani, D, Bouziotis, J, Boylan, M, Bozza, F, Brazzi, L, Brewster, D, Brickell, K, Broadley, T, Brozzi, N, Buchtele, N, Burrell, A, Cabral, S, Garces, R, Calligy, K, Campbell, P, Cardoso, S, Cardoso, F, Carelli, S, Carrier, F, Carson, G, Cascao, M, Casimiro, J, Castanheira, N, Castro, I, Catarino, A
بيانات النشر: John Wiley and Sons Inc
سنة النشر: 2023
المجموعة: Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca: BOA (Bicocca Open Archive)
مصطلحات موضوعية: ARDS, COVID-19, ECLS, extracorporeal life support, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, mortality, prediction score, Sars-Cov2, V-V ECMO
الوصف: Background: Veno-venous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (V-V ECMO) is a lifesaving support modality for severe respiratory failure, but its resource-intensive nature led to significant controversy surrounding its use during the COVID-19 pandemic. We report the performance of several ECMO mortality prediction and severity of illness scores at discriminating survival in a large COVID-19 V-V ECMO cohort. Methods: We validated ECMOnet, PRESET (PREdiction of Survival on ECMO Therapy-Score), Roch, SOFA (Sequential Organ Failure Assessment), APACHE II (acute physiology and chronic health evaluation), 4C (Coronavirus Clinical Characterisation Consortium), and CURB-65 (Confusion, Urea nitrogen, Respiratory Rate, Blood Pressure, age >65 years) scores on the ISARIC (International Severe Acute Respiratory and emerging Infection Consortium) database. We report discrimination via Area Under the Receiver Operative Curve (AUROC) and Area under the Precision Recall Curve (AURPC) and calibration via Brier score. Results: We included 1147 patients and scores were calculated on patients with sufficient variables. ECMO mortality scores had AUROC (0.58–0.62), AUPRC (0.62–0.74), and Brier score (0.286–0.303). Roch score had the highest accuracy (AUROC 0.62), precision (AUPRC 0.74) yet worst calibration (Brier score of 0.3) despite being calculated on the fewest patients (144). Severity of illness scores had AUROC (0.52–0.57), AURPC (0.59–0.64), and Brier Score (0.265–0.471). APACHE II had the highest accuracy (AUROC 0.58), precision (AUPRC 0.64), and best calibration (Brier score 0.26). Conclusion: Within a large international multicenter COVID-19 cohort, the evaluated ECMO mortality prediction and severity of illness scores demonstrated inconsistent discrimination and calibration highlighting the need for better clinically applicable decision support tools.
نوع الوثيقة: article in journal/newspaper
وصف الملف: STAMPA
اللغة: English
العلاقة: info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/pmid/37032544; info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/wos/WOS:000981903400001; volume:47; issue:9; firstpage:1490; lastpage:1502; numberofpages:13; journal:ARTIFICIAL ORGANS; https://hdl.handle.net/10281/479041Test; info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/scopus/2-s2.0-85157988558
DOI: 10.1111/aor.14542
الإتاحة: https://doi.org/10.1111/aor.14542Test
https://hdl.handle.net/10281/479041Test
رقم الانضمام: edsbas.F08B6E1
قاعدة البيانات: BASE