Background Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is underdiagnosed and therefore increasing the opportunities for HCV testing without venipuncture may be useful. Objectives We evaluated the analytical performance of a modified, commercially available, combined HCV antigen–antibody assay (cEIA) (Monolisa ® HCV-Ag-Ab-ULTRA) and a commercially available point-of-care (POC) device (OraQuick ® HCV) on fingerstick blood (FSB) and oral mucosal transudate (OMT). Study design FSB, OMT and serum samples were collected from 113 cases of HCV-antibody-positive patients and 88 HCV-antibody-negative controls. The HCV-antibody-positive group included 63 patients with quantifiable HCV-RNA (56%) and 17 HIV/HCV co-infected patients (15%). FSB and OMT specimens were collected as dried blood spots (DBSs) or with the OraSure collection system, before testing with cEIA. Results With FSB specimens, the cEIA and the POC device exhibited 100% specificity and 98.2% and 97.4% sensitivity, respectively. The specificity of the cEIA in FSB sharply decreased if stored 3 days at room temperature. With OMT specimens, the cEIA sensitivity (71.7%) and specificity (94.3%) were significantly lower than the performance of OraQuick ® HCV (sensitivity, 94.6%; specificity, 100%). The optical densities obtained with the cEIA in FSB and OMT were lower in HIV/HCV co-infected patients compared with HCV monoinfected patients. Conclusion The cEIA using FSB specimens collected on DBSs preserved in appropriate storage conditions was a reliable alternative, equivalent to the POC assay, for HCV testing without venipuncture. The cEIA was not adapted for HCV testing on OMT.